
Not All Sitting Is Created Equal
When my aunt reached a certain age, maybe in her 80s, she moved in with her daughter. She went from puttering around, taking care of her house, dog, and whatever yard work she could do to…well, mostly sitting in my cousin’s house.
After going to visit her sister, my mom came home and reported that my aunt was losing cognitive function. Mom pronounced, “I believe it’s because all she does is sit and watch soap operas all day!”
Thanks for reading TrainSmarter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Mom may have been onto something.
In a study recently reported in The Journal of the Alzheimer’s Association, researchers tracked 1700 adults for 20 years. Those middle-aged adults who watched the most television had smaller memory-related brain regions over 20 years later.
The study
The researchers had participants, who averaged 53 years old, rate how much they watched TV in their leisure time and how much of their workday they spent sitting.
Twenty years later, participants had brain MRIs. Those who reported watching TV most frequently differed greatly from those who watched the least. They had
smaller frontal and occipital lobes, involved in functions such as planning, judgment, and visual processing.
smaller volumes in brain regions associated with Alzheimer’s disease.
more areas indicating damage to the brain’s blood vessels, which is associated with greater risk of stroke, mood issues, memory loss, and dementia.
Heard the adage, “Sitting is the new smoking”?
Good news for desk workers—that brush is a little too broad. Turns out, it’s not so much what you do as how you do it.
In fact, people who spent much of their workday sitting had larger frontal and occipital lobes and fewer brain blood vessel lesions than the frequent TV watchers.
The researchers speculated that the issue is what the brain is doing while you’re sitting. That's an interesting distinction. Not all sedentary behavior appears to be associated with brain health in the same way.
Desk workers' brains are actively focusing, problem-solving, and processing.
Watching television is passive. I can think of more than a few shows that probably promote brain rot…
I’d love to know if your brain is affected differently by watching a National Geographic special, as opposed to watching people argue, gossip, and throw wine at each other on The Real Housewives.
Good news for women?
The greatest brain differences related to TV viewing and workplace sitting were found in men. The study didn’t speculate about the explanation for this.
But somehow, it didn’t surprise me. My mom never sat and watched something on TV. She was always busy with something. I rarely watch anything that I’m not multitasking with something work-related, either, which doesn’t make me great at remembering details about the show I just “watched.” Maybe it’s the generation I grew up in, but when family gathered, the women were in the kitchen preparing and cleaning up after the meal, while the men gathered in front of the TV. Would you say that’s still the case?
The caveats
This research doesn’t prove cause and effect, and relied on self-reported TV watching habits. There was no brain scan at the start, only at the end, so the researchers don’t know how significant the brain changes were.
The researchers adjusted for exercise, diabetes, body mass index, smoking, and alcohol to try to level the playing field. But one neuroscientist pointed out that people with desk jobs during that period might be more likely to be better educated and earn more, and therefore have better access to healthcare.
The two-edged sword of the screen
How might time spent in front of the TV compare with phone and computer screens?
A 2025 study reported that those screens provide “valuable opportunities for cognitive stimulation, skill-building, and maintaining independence in midlife and older adulthood,” for people with healthy cognition and mild cognitive impairment alike. Used well, they can foster learning, curiosity, and social connection, all of which support healthy aging.
On the other hand, the authors list risks, including “attention deficits, disrupted sleep patterns, social isolation, reduced physical activity, and structural brain changes that could accelerate cognitive decline and dementia onset.”
Mindless scrolling and passive TV watching may also add to "visual fatigue, chronic distraction, and sedentary behaviors."
Quality, not quantity alone, appears to shape the brain effects of screens
While sitting for extended periods doing activities that challenge your mind may be good for your brain, extended sedentary time focused on a screen isn’t good for your body—or your eyes!
Toward healthier downtime
Learn something new. We have clients who are learning to play the piano and learning another language.
Connect with a friend or family member. Social connection is critical for your health!
Get up and move around hourly, at a minimum. That’s good for your body, brain, and eyesight. I always have something I need to get up and do, even if it’s going out to check the mail.
Do your mobility exercises while you’re watching TV. 😉
You do have to wonder—is the issue the time spent staring at the television or what that time replaces? Or both? I know what Mom thought—what do you think?